To the greatest genre in the world
Though I enjoy a lot of different types of music, anyone who's read me knows that power-pop has been my absolute favorite genre for years. It's actually kind of a shame, because thorough and informative web sites like Pitchfork and indie snobs in general dimiss power-pop faster than you can say Isaac Brock sucks dick.I've heard all the criticisms: The lyrics are vapid, the songs repetitive, there's not enough layer and depth, the music's too happy, etc. Those who don't enjoy it always employ a holier-than-thou "Well it can't be good if it actually has discernible hooks, gets lodged in your head immediately, makes you want to sing along and doesn't drearily plod along for four to six minutes" attitude. Apparently happy music = bad music in the indie world.
I've never listened to music to be challenged or find some sort of deep, hidden meaning. I couldn't give a flying fuck what a band has to say. If I want to be intellectually stimulated I'll pick up a book, watch Jeopardy or do the Times crossword. When it comes to music, all I care about is getting a song stuck in my head and making me want to play it over and over again until I get sick of it.
To me, that's the beauty of power-pop: The bands get right to the point, with the songs drenched in sunny harmonies, sugary-sweet lead vocals and a perfect smattering of minor chords, to ensure you will be singing their songs for days on end. It amazes me that people who are interested in immediately catchy music are very much in the minority. When did this happen? The last (and really only time) power-pop was commercially viable was with The Beatles. One could argue that a handful of 70s power-pop bands had a reasonable degree of success, but the genre's been the redheaded stepchild of the music industry ever since.
Fortunately, there are still plenty of bands making amazing, catchy-as-fuck music - you just have to know how to find them. The power-pop community is severely underserved on the Internet - I've long wished for a power-pop version of Pitchfork (surely there are enough of us out there to support a site with multiple daily reviews and news?), but that seems highly unlikely.
However, I have managed to uncover a handful of outstanding sites that have served my power-pop needs. During the last year, the indispensible Absolute Power Pop has solidified its place as one of the top sites in the genre, while Power Popaholic has also done a commendable job. Of course, neither of these guys has the time to post every day, making a full-service power-pop site even more of a necessity.
Given the relative dearth of new power-pop reviews and information, I was devastated to discover that Whit's Brain - the gold standard of power-pop websites - is going to be shutting down. Not only has no other destination introduced me to as much amazing new music as Whit's has, but it's also responsible for three of my absolute favorite bands: The Argument, Second Saturday and Yellow Second, whose third and final album, "Altitude," is the flat-out best album of the decade. It's truly a huge loss for the community, and I only hope that Whit is able to set up shop somewhere else in the future.
A sincere thank you to Whit's for years of great music. You will be missed.
Labels: Absolute Power Pop, Altitude, NY Times Crossword, Pitchfork, Power pop, Power Popaholic, Second Saturday, The Argument, Yellow Second



4 Comments:
Hey,
Right on, my friend. Powerpop is, indeed, an overlooked genre. I suppose one could make arguments for Fountains of Wayne and a few others breaking through to mainstrem. But, folks like that are rarely given "credibility" with the tastemakers. Thankfully that doesn't seem to stop the plethora of bands from doing their thing.
I'm fortunate enough to be in Seattle, which has a healthy dose of this stuff going on with groups like The Tripwires, Young Sportsmen, The Capillaries, Shake Some Action, The Small Change, and a ton more. (shameless plug alert). See the Seattle Powerpop Blog.
Amen again to you, brother. I will add a link and spread the word!
- The Powerpopaholic
www.powerpopaholic.com
Amen to your insights and kudos to Steve, Gary, and Aaron for the great work they're doing at Absolute Powerpop, Seattle-Powerpop, and Powerpopaholic. I've learned tons from them. I started Powerpopulist (http://powerpopulist.blogspot,com)back in October mainly to hunt down and post songs I find and like in the powerpop/indie vein. Come one, come all!
Well said and and hear, hear! A few thoughts:
1) Just as actors and critics often look down on comedy compared to drama, music that is upbeat and/or "positive" is often seen as superficial or somehow less important than music that is angry or challenging or disturbing. It's largely a form of snobbery, IMHO.
2) In some ways, power pop falls between categories: it's rock, so if you don't like rock you'll think it's too noisy, but if you like hard rock or metal, it may sound too soft.
3) If it's not hip or cool, the kids won't listen to it so it has a strike against it re mass appeal, and thus the suits in the suites don't want to promote it.
4) Despite all that, I think the music industry is missing an opportunity, because lots of people would like this sort of music if they could hear it and knew how to buy it. How many radio stations play this sort of music? In San Francisco, zero. Is it available at Best Buy or Wal-Mart? No. Is it a labeled category at the local record store? Probably not. But how many people loved (and still love) the theme song to Friends? Millions. (By the way, all power pop fans should hear the theme song to the TV show The Class. Anyone know who did it?)
Post a Comment
<< Home